Vietnam and US versus China over oil in the sea

23 May 2014 04:32 am - 0 - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}

A A A

Who makes the law of the sea as China and Vietnam clash over China moving an oil rig close to an island only 25 miles from the mainland of Vietnam?
One would hope that China, which has ratified the Law of the Sea Treaty, which among its other virtues has an arbitrating court for such disputes, would seek international, but disinterested arbitration. It refuses to.

Has this got something to do with the fact that the US has not ratified the Treaty? The Chinese don’t say so explicitly, but if the world’s one and the only superpower refuses to sign up why should China pay the Treaty due regard? Is that what China is thinking? It is not a very good reason, but conceivably an understandable one.

In 1979 President Jimmy Carter decided to file suit against Iran before the International Court of Justice (the World Court) for taking US diplomats as hostage

As for the US itself it has an awful track record in ratifying international treaties, usually thanks to the Senate’s habitual blocking behaviour. It takes only one-third of the Senate to stymie a treaty. Even though, to give one example, the US played an important, and usually constructive, role in bringing into the world the International Criminal Court (ICC) for prosecuting war crimes and crimes against humanity and US President, Bill Clinton wanted the US to sign up, the threat by the Senate that “it would be dead on arrival,” in the words of Senator Jesse Helms, meant that it was never submitted for ratification.

Nevertheless, as is often the case with the US, it supports the ICC’s work in day to day practice. It does the same with the Law of the Sea. Still, failing to ratify makes the US position rather weak when it tries to lean on China to get off Vietnam’s back.

David Kaye writes in Foreign Affairs that the Senate “rejects treaties as if it were a sport”. After the First World War it rejected the US joining the League of Nations, the precursor to the United Nations. Perhaps membership would have helped avert the rise of Nazi Germany by forging a more sensitive and united policy over German reparations, one of Germany’s sore points that Hitler played upon. Who knows? But maybe.

In more recent times the US rejected the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Treaty, the Kyoto Protocol on climate change, the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty and the Convention on the Rights of the Child (which only two other countries besides the US have failed to sign --Somalia and South Sudan).

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (later used to justify the US’s military campaign against the “ethnic cleansing” policies of the then Yugoslavian President Slobodan Milosevic) was ratified by the US in 1988, forty years after it signed it. But this was only because the right wing President Ronald Reagan made a supreme effort to convince his fellow Republicans in the Senate, as he also did successfully with the Anti-Torture Convention.

As for the US itself it has an awful track record in ratifying international treaties, usually thanks to the Senate’s habitual blocking behaviour. It takes only one-third of the Senate to stymie a treaty

It was 26 years and after 109 other states had signed up that the US ratified the International Convention on Human Rights, an instrument which it waged a long campaign for China to sign up to and which it now uses to upbraid China’s human rights abuses. The US has still not ratified the other principal treaty enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The omission allows many countries, including China, to accuse the US of having double standards on human rights. The US, it is said, supports human rights such as democracy or habeas corpus but doesn’t support the right to have a job, education and health (as it used to be until President Barack Obama won his health reform bill).

But all cannot be blamed on the Senate. In 1979 President Jimmy Carter decided to file suit against Iran before the International Court of Justice (the World Court) for taking US diplomats as hostage. Yet, only four years later, when Nicaragua took the US to Court for the mining of the harbour of its principal port, the US under President Ronald Reagan withdrew its membership of the Court.

In 1998 the World Court ordered that the execution of a Paraguayan citizen in the US be suspended. It argued that under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, to which the US is a party, the accused had the right to seek assistance from Paraguayan consular officials, which he had been denied. Five days later, ignoring the Court, the state authorities in Virginia proceeded with the execution.

Some of the above has only a tangential relationship with what is going on between Vietnam and China at the moment. But much relates to it. The US has failed to be credible in a good many parts of the international arena.

The US has lived with its moral and diplomatic ambiguities over the application of international law for too long. If it wants other countries to toe the line it has to toe the line itself

Order Gifts and Flowers to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Grocery, Kids Toys, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Money Remittence,Astrology, Courier/Delivery, Medicine Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop into Sri Lanka

Comments - 0

Add comment
Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Vietnam and US versus China over oil in the sea

Comments - 0

Add comment

RECOMMENDED

‘Spike in blast fishing’ poses renewed threats to Sri Lanka’s marine ecosystems

UDA owned land in Thalawathugoda; UDA Minister Prasanna Ranatunga under the spotlight for forceful occupation of reserved land

Loss-making SMIB faces political pressure in recovering loans

Baltimore Bridge Collapse: MV Dali, SL authorities anchored in mystery?

Has Sri Lanka become a potential hub for the illegal wildlife trade?

Spotlight on Moragahakanda Development Project Moragolla villagers lose livelihoods and down to one meal a day

Ambitious Sri Lankan jobseekers ‘trafficked into Ukraine war zones’

Most Viewed in News

Two racing drivers arrested over Fox Hill tragedy

Complaint lodged over Piumi Hansamali's possession of Gota’s Range Rover

New Visa procedure implemented

Ranil Wickremesinghe caravan moves on despite barking dogs

Racing event tragedy leaves seven dead including eight-year-old child

Street food vendor arrested for verbally harassing foreigner

MIRROR CRICKET

Is Chamari Athapaththu Sri Lanka’s greatest cricketer ever?

Athapaththu back atop ICC Women’s ODI Batting Rankings

Chamari Athapaththu sets big goal for T20 World Cup

How does CSK get best out of Pathirana?

TODAY'S HEADLINES

Foreign powers intensify surveillance on Presidential elections as strategic interests take centre stage

New uterine loop for monkey birth control

Sajith avoids reception hosted for Iranian President

Do not be afraid to use weapons, Minister Alles tells police

SLAS appoints independent committee for investigation

Pakistan lose key players for last two T20Is against New Zealand

Sri Lanka secures third spot in South Asian Kurash Championship 2024

Athapaththu back atop ICC Women’s ODI Batting Rankings