Middle East economies are unable to shift into top gear

29 March 2013 06:30 pm - 2 - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}

A A A

Unless they change gears the mystery would remain unsolved

It has always been one of the mysteries of history why it is that the Muslim world of the Middle East was once so far ahead of Europe in science, medicine, astronomy and mathematics yet by the 16th century started to fall behind.

Not only did most of it never industrialise, if it hadn’t been for nearly all its countries having oil in abundance they would still be living in the poverty and torpor that was their lot at the beginning of the twentieth century. Even today as modernism takes over and cities are built like this one and its neighbours, reaching for the sky, the foundations are industries of the newer kind- tourism and banking. According to the UN’s annual Human Development Report most of them, Abu Dhabi apart, compared with countries of equal income per head, are low down in the world rankings on education, health, scientific prowess and the status of women.
But why did the Muslim world lose its momentum? If it had kept going at the pace it did in the first millennium after Mohammed it would now be one of the world’s leaders.

The problem has been Islamic law. It has imposed a straight-jacket on economic development, even though Mohammed argued in favour of private property, commerce and personal enrichment. Europe and Asia were less bound.

We can single out a number of laws - the law of contracts, the inheritance system, marriage and regulations on hereditary.

Traditionally, Moslem business men usually formed partnerships but the death of a partner terminated the partnership automatically. Active partners carried full liability; there were no bankruptcy laws. The firm’s assets were exposed to demands from third partners. Inheritance laws spread ownership into small parcels among many heirs. Polygamy multiplied the problem. The Koran has detailed rules on inheritance. While giving women more rights than they were given in Europe the sum effect was to make economic progress circumscribed. Moreover, apostasy laws whose breaking could be punishable by death, made it impossible to do business under a non-Muslim system, making international commerce difficult.

Banks could not be established to provide the large-scale financing necessary for mass transport, mass communications and for the factories of mass manufacturing.
In Europe where church and state were separate there was much more freedom for new ideas and new ventures. In Islam theology ruled almost everything.
If this were still the picture today the Muslim countries would be stuck in the worst of ruts.

Pioneered by the Ottoman Empire, Ataturk’s Turkey and the sizeable secular component of Egyptian society, change was introduced from the mid 19th century onwards and slowly spread to other parts of the Muslim world. Things have definitely changed but not as much as they need to. Old attitudes and practises still exist. The apostasy laws still are invoked, if not always and consistently.

In the 1850s Egypt and Turkey, attempting to fast forward, brought in French legal practices. But it took time for judges to be trained and new norms of law to be inculcated. Nepotism and corruption remained rampant, the inheritance of a personal way of dealing with matters that should be decided by disinterested judges.

Pre-modern institutions created bloated bureaucracies which are alive and well today. Government policies and conservative social instincts hamper creativity and competition. Thus their manufacturing exports - Turkey excepted - are largely unable to make it in the world at large. Even if the dead hand of top down decision making were swept aside it would take decades for development to take off, apart from the oil, banking and tourism sectors.

Losing the race against Europe led to the rise of protectionism. Turkish statism, Arab socialism and Islamism all at different times have inhibited the capitalist urge to create, invest and grow.

Today the influence of Islamic law has diminished, not least because of Western pressure. The pace was set by Muslim Turkey that in the 1920s abrogated its old, Islamic laws in their entirety. Even in the conservative Arab peninsula they have been modified beyond recognition. Today the corporation is a popular organisational form. Banks are alive and well in every country, working at home and abroad under different systems of jurisprudence. Coming late to the party the Middle East has been able to borrow modern institutions in their most advanced forms.

Yet the populace, even secular intellectuals who are not attached to Islamic practices, have a tendency to blame the West for its development failures rather than their own regimes. The role of classical Islamic law in historically blocking economic development is understood by relatively few, argues Professor Timur Kuran in his new book, “The Long Divergence”.

Unless the Muslim world can change gears and up its annual GNP growth to a consistent 8% or more (which only Qatar is doing) the West will continue to widen the gap. It’s a bad scenario.

Order Gifts to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Vegetables, Grocery, Flowers, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Sending Money,Online Books, Delivery Service, Food Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop Sri Lanka

Comments - 2

dIREsTRAITS Sunday, 31 March 2013 11:17 AM

Funny how if islamic banking and finance principles were followed we wouldn't have seen the financial crisis where by the poor got robbed left, right and center and they don't even know it. The answer to the decline lies between your lines. With the need for oil the west made sure its cronies (e.g. Saudi royal family, Hosni Mubaarak, Gaddafi, Saddam Hussain) were put in place to keep the poor in a perpetual hibernation.

Asad Monday, 01 April 2013 12:00 AM

good attempt to talk about Islamic law. but you have to learn more sir. pls read the Quran fully for additional references via DM Android App

Add comment
Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Middle East economies are unable to shift into top gear

Comments - 2

Add comment

RECOMMENDED

Sri Lankan graduates lured to work in online dating scams in Laos

Dispute over Kinthusity Cemetery as caste issue surfaces

75 Years of Independence and the Tamils of Sri Lanka

Jeevan sets a record as Lanka’s youngest-ever Cabinet Minister

TNA was Born in 2001 Due to Elections Shock of 2000

Pain and punishment

Health System in the emergency room

Most Viewed in News

Father Chandra Schaffter speaks his heart out about Dinesh’s death and Dinesh, the person

Body of a Sri Lankan billionaire businessman found in Jakarta

Millions allocated for former presidents in 2023, Treasury makes no cuts

Suspect confesses over killing Thalangama businessman, both suspect and victim were part of gay men’s club

Missing businessman found dead at his luxury building swimming pool

Despite economic crisis, Treasury allocates billions for Offices of President, PM, Ministers

TODAY'S HEADLINES

Paris Club provides much-needed assurance IMF funds almost in Sri Lanka’s hands

Crucial sectors to come to a standstill today opposing taxes

Charmer invited home to cure father ends up raping minor girl

Hundreds rushing for bogus Turkey job opportunity ALFEASL says don’t fall prey to fake job scams and lose money

MIRROR CRICKET

Croospulle shines in rain shortened day

Selectors await invitation to pick squads for New Zealand tour

Sports Ministry to advertise for cricket selectors

St. Anthony’s records win against Ananda after 74 years

Croospulle shines in rain shortened day

Hangzhou Asian Games 2023 Sri Lanka Official Fun Run at Port City tomorrow

Selectors await invitation to pick squads for New Zealand tour

Kandy SC record comfortable 37-28 victory