Tue, 28 Mar 2023 Today's Paper

CCC slams govt. for imposing price controls on high-demand drugs

7 November 2016 09:01 am - 6     - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}


Sri Lanka’s premier trade chamber, Ceylon Chamber of Commerce (CCC), yesterday in a strongly-worded statement slammed the government’s move towards introducing price controls for certain medicinal drugs saying it limits the customer choice and distorts the market place.  To the much surprise of the country’s pharmaceutical sector stakeholders, the Health Ministry through a gazette notification hastily introduced price controls on 48 high-demand drugs, presumably with the good intention of creating public access to medicinal drugs at affordable prices.

Though the intentions may have been good, the CCC noted that such ad-hoc moves, distorting the market, could have a lot of negative unintended consequences to the consumer, market place as well as to the overall country’s economy.

“It severely impacts private sector decision making, harms Sri Lanka’s international standing as an open economy, restricts consumers/patients ability to make free choices based on their individual affordability, and creates overall distortionary effects that hamper a smooth functioning of markets,” CCC said. And added, “The CCC strongly urges the government to refrain from introducing ad-hoc, poorly designed and unviable regulations, that cause undesirable market distortions and undermines the country’s overall socio-economic goals.”

As the trade chamber points out, Sri Lanka has a strong and accessible public healthcare system, complemented by a quality private healthcare system that is catering to evolving needs of the Sri Lankan people.
While all Sri Lankans, regardless of socio-economic conditions, have access to free public healthcare, patients have the freedom to seek private healthcare as well, particularly medicinal drugs from private providers. In this context, the CCC argues that the new pricing rules are hurting the efficient operation of the private healthcare market and are hurting consumer choice.

 While Sri Lanka has a small local pharmaceutical manufacturing industry, it accounts for approximately less than 10 percent of the private sector supply and 90 percent is supplied by private firms who are the designated local agents for pharmaceuticals imported from international principals.  It is these private providers who largely import ‘generics’ or ‘branded generics’ and ‘originators’.

According to the CCC the new pricing system that has been announced is one derived from the Indian model, suitable for a large domestic market with a substantial domestic drug-manufacturing base and not for Sri Lanka.
“This pricing mechanism uses the median price of any drug that commands a 2 percent or more market share (by volume). In most instances, the median price is a branded Indian generic due to the large volumes of such drugs sold in the Sri Lankan market. As a result, most ‘originator’ brands are faced with an unviable ceiling price, that is neither reflective of cost nor of quality.”

“This also means that prices of such drugs would be well below regional ceiling prices, which international providers operate on the basis of. The international firms would not want to subject their products to the possibility of unofficial arbitrage trade in the region, originating from Sri Lanka,” the CCC pointed out.  The trade chamber said it was aware of incidents over the past week of authorities having to seize drugs being brought illegally, as baggage goods by travellers, and all of these are items coming under the new price controls.

“This is a clear indication of how economic actors will attempt to circumvent unviable controls,” CCC stressed.
Meanwhile, with the majority of Sri Lanka’s pharmaceutical drug requirements depend on imports, where costs vary with every shipment due to exchange rate variability, fixed prices become highly infeasible, CCC pointed out.
Echoing recent statement by the country pharma chamber, Sri Lanka Chamber of Pharmaceutical Industry (SLCPI), the CCC said ‘branded generic’ and ‘originator’ drugs are strongly impacted by the new pricing rules, and can result in shortages as well as restrict patients’ choice.

“Early reports indicate that several originator drug companies have signaled they would discontinue supplying to the Sri Lankan market,” CCC noted.

In this backdrop, the trade chamber urged the pharma regulator to consider an ‘automatic pass through’ for exchange rate volatilities, where a quarterly revision of prices is linked to Central Bank approved exchange rate.
“In the absence of such a mechanism, a devaluation for instance would result in each pharma importer requiring NMRA pricing committee approval for price increases on all products stemming from a change over which the importer has no control.”

Point out another possible dangerous scenario, the CCC warned that the recent gazette could prevent higher quality drugs developed with innovation in the originator countries coming into Sri Lanka
“This affects not only individual choice of consumers, but also affects the country’s ability to continually access the newest medication. Moreover, price controls can lead to the proliferation of lower quality and counterfeit drugs, which is dangerous to public health,” CCC cautioned.

Meanwhile, CCC said industry representatives, affiliated to the chamber, had pointed out that changes were made in an ad hoc manner and without full consultation with key industry stakeholders.

“Moreover, the suggestion made by industry bodies of implementing a verifiable CIF (like in Saudi Arabia, Malaysia and Singapore) where it can be ensured that the CIF offered to Sri Lanka is not higher than the region, had not been given full consideration.

While the industry had clearly indicated support for a rational pricing mechanism, the process under which the new price controls were implemented is far from desirable,” CCC said.

  Comments - 6

  • Kaboos Monday, 07 November 2016 09:38 AM

    Ceylon chamber of commerce will try to safe guard the interest of wealthy pharmaceutical company. The company employers are there members and they survive with their subscriptions. The government should ignore their statement.

    Don Monday, 07 November 2016 09:53 AM

    These people are the enemy of the state. Health care is not a business its a right. via DM Android App

    Patient Monday, 07 November 2016 10:13 AM

    First check whether International Pharmaceutical mafia has bought over the CCC via DM Android App

    fayaz Monday, 07 November 2016 10:13 AM

    fcid needs to investigate the persons who made these allegations. via DM Android App

    Nethra Monday, 07 November 2016 10:46 AM

    Recently a pharmacist revealed the a tablet was sold atRs.270/- after price reduction it has come down toRs.70/- what a such big margin the importer has kept,the innocent doctors to prescribe the brand without knowing the price price factor.Please don't alarm without studying cost the unnecessaryforeign exchange flown out of hard earned House maids and poor estate workers.

    Dr. Who Monday, 07 November 2016 10:49 AM

    It is not the Patients choice, it is Us, Doctors who offer high priced medicines to patients. And for that we also benefit. With this move no free family trips, commissions, free samples, etc, etc. etc. The Government is so insensitive in this regard. Foreign governments should intervene. high proft making drug manufacturing companies should negotiate with the concerned parties. The government should compensate the income of doctors that get reduced. :P

Add comment

Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Reply To:

Name - Reply Comment

Import of South Indian eggs: Sri Lanka walks on Indian eggshells

With the increase in egg prices the government decided to import eggs to regu

Wokeism: Is it destructive, or are you afraid of change? A response

In order to critically discuss a movement, we must first understand its etymo

Defeat in Ananthapuram Battle denoted the LTTE’s end

Many battles were fought during the long war between the Sri Lankan armed for

Wokeism: A Weapon of Mass Destruction?

When can one say they’ve had enough of being in a state of ‘wokeness’ a