Mon, 30 Jan 2023 Today's Paper

Mega Cor ruption Everywhere - Real Action Nowhere ?

8 December 2015 07:02 pm - 0     - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}



Commencing from as far back as 1970 with the Kyoto Declaration, the process for the formulation of the UN Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) commenced in December 2000, with the UN General Assembly resolving to establish a Committee for negotiating and formulating the UNCAC. With several subsequent meetings, UNCAC was formulated and adopted by the UN General Assembly in October 2003, and December 9 was designated as the ‘International Anti-Corruption day’. The UNCAC came into force in December 2005, upon 30 States having ratified the same. Sri Lanka was the second State to have ratified in March 2004, under Prime Minister, Ranil Wickremesinghe. As at now 177 States have become parties to the UNCAC, the Secretariat and custodian of which is the UNODC. 
On the heels of the UNCAC coming into force in December 2005, mooted by UNODC the International Association of Anti-Corruption Authorities (IAACA) was inaugurated in October 2006, with the objectives of promoting and facilitating the implementation of the UNCAC. IAACA held its 8th Annual Conference in November 2015 at St. Petersburg, Russia, preceding the  6th Session of the Conference of State Parties (COSP6) to UNCAC held also at St. Petersburg. Russia recognizing the need to combat corruption, itself, is a global achievement, and reflects the pace at which this international movement against corruption is growing. 

The UN ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’, came into force, as far back as 1948, and has thus developed in its enforcement. On the other hand, UNCAC came into force 57 years thereafter, only 10 years ago, and its development and growth is becoming, not only widespread, but also in depth, even reverberating at the highest levels of States. Sri Lanka after a lapse of several years, participated with a Delegation led by Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Dr. Harsha de Silva.

UNODC Executive Director Yury Fedotov at the G-20 States Meeting in Paris in April 2011 emphatically stated thus:
“Corruption has the power to shake the very foundations of society. Even in regions where peace and prosperity prevail, corruption takes a heavy toll ….. Now it’s time for business to move beyond declarations to concrete actions ….. Anti-Corruption Action Plan provides a common approach and an opportunity for the G-20 to lead by example in the global fight against corruption ….. In October this year, the Conference of States Parties to the Convention against Corruption will meet in Marrakech, Morocco to take stock of global progress in preventing corruption …… The UN Convention against Corruption is the first legally binding global anti-corruption instrument. It obliges States to prevent and criminalize corruption, promote international cooperation, recover stolen assets and improve technical assistance and information exchange.” 

Conference of State Parties in November 2015 and ‘Sustainable Development Agenda 2030’
United Nations at its Conference in Paris in September 2015 formulated a ‘Sustainable Development Agenda’ to be achieved during the 15 years by 2030. Goal No. 16 therein is to ‘promote just, peaceful and inclusive societies’. Some of the specific targets thereunder are to ‘promote the rule of law at national and international levels and to ensure equal access to justice for all’; further significantly to ‘substantially reduce corruption and bribery in all their forms’; and also to ‘ensure public access to information and to protect fundamental freedoms’. It is in this background that the COSP6 regarding the UNCAC was held in St. Petersburg, Russia in November 2015, on the conclusion of which, a Statement was released by UNODC Executive Director, Yury Fedotov.

Extracts from UNODC Chief’s Statement – November 2015
“I am pleased to address you at the closing of the 6th session of the Conference of the States Parties to the UN Convention against Corruption-COSP6. Over the last five days, your discussions have done much to continue the global fight against corruption and bribery. As I stated in my opening speech, and I wish to stress once again, countering corruption today is necessary to achieve the sustainable development goals of tomorrow. And our achievements in St. Petersburg this week are closely linked to the UN’s overall work. 

There have been many references to the Sustainable Development Goals and 2030 Agenda during this session. It is clear that Goal 16, which recognizes the need to address corruption, is essential to the new development agenda.

States parties are openly acknowledging that preventing corruption and bribery, and the achievement of the 2030 Agenda, are mutually reinforcing. These views underline UNCAC’s importance to the UN’s global efforts. 

This week in St. Petersburg, States Parties have agreed to launch the second cycle of reviewing the implementation of the Convention. It will start next year with looking at how countries prevent corruption and facilitate asset recovery. 

Over this last week, we have held more than 30 high-level events, as well as dozens of sessions, meetings, informal and other types of discussions. Valuable discussions have taken place and important decisions adopted ranging from public private partnerships to addressing the needs of small island developing States, and from academic initiatives to confronting the corruption connected to wildlife and forest crime.  Thanks to the ambitious adoption of the SDG’s the noble purpose of this Conference, and the work of the implementation review mechanism, have been given renewed purpose and energy. UNCAC was already a highly innovative Convention, but with the new development agenda, we have been given a fresh sense of mission; one that we must not fail. We know that people across the world yearn for access to justice and transparent institutions, and the elimination of the corruption and bribery that makes their lives far harder and far more expensive.

In closing, ladies and Gentlemen, let me also say that COSP6 was witness to a very important event. This was the first time that a message was addressed to the conference by the UN Secretary-General at the opening session.

Allow me to quote from his statement:
“All of us have a reason to eliminate corruption and to create societies founded on justice, fairness and the rule of law.  The world counts on you to take bold decisions and act decisively to strengthen the global fight against corruption and bribery.” As we make our return journeys, I ask you to give thought to the Secretary-General’s words and to do what is necessary to strengthen the fight against global corruption. UNODC stands ready to support you in the work that lies ahead. Together, we can turn his stirring words into a reality that can advance the new development agenda and help 
millions of people.”

Articles of the UNCAC
The UNCAC applies with equal force to the public and private sectors, where public resources are managed, either by the public sector or by the private sector. The very Index of Articles of the UNCAC set out below brings out its scope:- Articles of the Convention
1. PREAMBLE                                                                 
Article 1  Statement of Purpose            
Article 2 Use of terms                           
Article 3 Scope of application               
Article 4  Protection of sovereignty       
Article 5 - Preventive anti-corruption     policies and practices  
Article 6 - Preventive anti-corruption body or bodies             
Article 7 - Public sector           
Article 8 - Codes of conduct for public officials      
Article 9 - Public procurement and management of public finances     
Article 10 - Public reporting      
Article 11 - Measures relating to the judiciary and prosecution services                
Article 12 - Private sector          
Article 13 - Participation of society           
Article 14  -  Measures to prevent money-laundering
Article 15  - Bribery of national public officials         
Article 16 - Bribery of foreign public officials and officials of public International organizations          
Article 17 - Embezzlement, misappropriation or other diversion of property by a public official          
Article 18 - Trading in influence                
Article 19 - Abuse of functions  
Article 20 - Illicit enrichment    
Article 21 - Bribery in the private sector   
Article 22 - Embezzlement of property in the private sector   
Article 23 - Laundering of proceeds of crime           
Article 24 - Concealment           
Article 25 - Obstruction of justice             
Article 26 - Liability of legal persons        
Article 27 - Participation and attempt      
Article 28 - Knowledge, intent and purpose as elements of an offence  
Article 29 - Statute of limitations             
Article 30 - Prosecution, adjudication and sanctions                
Article 31 - Freezing, seizure and confiscation         
Article 32 - Protection of witnesses, experts and victims        
Article 33 - Protection of reporting persons                             
Article 34 - Consequences of acts of corruption       
Article 35 - Compensation for damage     
Article 36 - Specialized authorities           
Article 37 - Cooperation with law enforcement authorities    
Article 38 - Cooperation among national authorities            
Article 39 - Cooperation between national authorities and the private sector
Article 40 - Bank secrecy           
Article 41 - Criminal record       
Article 42 - Jurisdiction              
Article 43  - International cooperation       
Article 44 - Extradition              
Article 45  - Transfer of sentenced persons               
Article 46 - Mutual legal assistance         
Article 47 - Transfer of criminal proceedings           
Article 48 - Law enforcement cooperation               
Article 49 - Joint investigations 
Article 50 - Special investigative techniques            
Article 51 - General provision   
Article 52 - Prevention and detection of transfers of proceeds of crime 
Article 53 - Measures for direct recovery of property              
Article 54 - Mechanisms for recovery of property through international cooperation in confiscation    
Article 55 - International cooperation for purposes of confiscation        
Article 56 - Special cooperation                
Article 57 - Return and disposal of assets                
Article 58 - Financial intelligence unit      
Article 59 - Bilateral and multilateral agreements and arrangements   
Article 60 - Training and technical assistance          
Article 61 - Collection, exchange and analysis of information on corruption
Article 62 - Other measures: implementation of the Convention through 
economic development and technical assistance 
Article 63 - Conference of the States Parties to the Convention              
Article 64 - Secretariat              
Article 65 - Implementation of the Convention        
Article 66 - Settlement of disputes           
Article 67 - Signature, ratification, acceptance, approval and accession                
Article 68 - Entry into force       
Article 69 - Amendment            
Article 70 - Denunciation           
Article 71 - Depositary and languages 

Multi-Stakeholder Approach 
At previous Annual Conferences having dealt in depth with the contents of the Articles of the UNCAC, the IAACA Annual Conference in November 2015 was on the theme ‘Prevention and Education’, vis-à-vis, combatting corruption; and IAACA issued a Declaration, inter-alia, calling upon State Parties to further embrace a comprehensive multi-stakeholder approach to combatting corruption, and to strengthen the discussions among Governments, civil society, academia and the private sector, in order to garnish support for the implementation of the UNCAC, as reflected by the UNODC Chief’s Statement at the conclusion of COSP6.

At high-level discussions and sessions, the private sectors’ duty and obligation to conform with the UNCAC was emphasized, with suggestions of public-private partnerships to combat the cancerous menace of corruption. Politicians from the public sector and professionals from the private sector carry a greater burdens, duties and responsibilities towards ensuring the conformity with the Articles of the UNCAC. 

As a consequence of the development of enforcing the implementation of the UNCAC, State Parties completed the first cycle of a Implementation Review of Mechanism, where randomly selected States were reviewed by other States. Though this brings about an educative process and exchange of information among States focused on implementation of the UNCAC, it is a tragic-comedy, where a less corrupt State is reviewed by a more corrupt State! The second cycle of the Implementation Review Mechanism is to commence. However, the results of such Implementation Review of Mechanism are not yet made public, though civil society is the appropriate sector to ensure compliance by their respective States, as demonstrated by public outcries against mega corruption by citizens in several States.

Many a Government comes to power avowing to combat fraud and corruption, but once installed in power,they gets bogged down in the very quagmire of fraud and corruption, with allegations and scandals. It was encouraging to observe at the high-level discussions, Delegates urging towards the creation of an International Court for civil society to hold accountable and responsible political leaders of States, who have embezzled the resources of the people,blatantly stifling Anti-Corruption Agencies, since endeavours thereafter to hold them accountable and responsible and to prosecute are seen to be thwarted by socio-political influences, partiality and political compulsions. 

It is the civil society that should be called upon to play a pivotal role in the combat against fraud and corruption and to ensure the effective enforcement of the rule of law. Insatiable avarise by a socio-politically powerful few to pillage and plunder the resources of the people,results in the denial to the vast multitude of the impoverished poor their dire needs of livelihood, including food, healthcare, education, housing, et al, which in effect is a violation of human rights, and needs to be so addressed. Pope Francis quoting the Bible once having pronounced that - “the necks of the corrupt persons should be tied to a rock and they be thrown into the sea”,and describing that “persons engaged in corruption appear beautiful from outside, but are full of dead bones and putrefactions inside”, His Holiness during the recent visit to Africa severely castigated corruption as further impoverishing the poor. 

In a World Bank Staff Working Paper No. 580, David J. Gould and Jose A. Amaro-Reyes reported that:
“Corruption is pervasive in the countries of Asia, Africa and Latin America. The government monopoly of economic activities in developing countries, when combined with conditions of political ‘softness’, widespread poverty and socio-economic inequalities, ambivalence towards the legitimacy of government and its organisations and systematic maladministration, provide fertile grounds for corruption, which ... has a deleterious, often devastating effect on administrative performance and economic and political development, for example corroding public confidence, perverting institutions’ processes and even goals, favouring the privileged and powerful few, and stimulating illegal capital export or use of non-rational criteria in public decisions.”   

Nevertheless, SAARC countries enmeshed in mega corruption, at their Heads of State Summits have never dealt with the issue of corruption, whilst ironically lamenting on the poverty of the impoverished poor in the region.  

The above perception that fraud and corruption were pervasive in less develop- ed States was proven wrong by Enron and WorldCom frauds and the fall of the reputed Auditors,Arthur Anderson, resulting in the enactment of Sarbanes-Oxley Act in the US. Thereafter financial scams in 2008 in the US and Europe by supposedly respected Banks and financial institutions caused such economic impact, for Governments to step in to bail them out, with ‘stimulus’ packages, whilst leading financial institutions, such as Lehman Brothers went into bankruptcy. In December 2014, it was reported that UBS, Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) and HSBC had agreed to pay a total of US $ 3.3 billion in fines on probes among Regulators in the US and Europe. It is the civil society agitations on a platform of major corruption allegations, which led to the installation in office of the present Government, committed to combat corruption and ensure good governance. This led to  Article 46 of the Nineteenth Amendment to the Constitution, introducing  Article 156A(1)(c) which stipulated that “Parliament shall by law provide for measures to implement the United Nations Convention Against Corruption and any other International Convention relating to the prevention of corruption, to which Sri Lanka is a party.” 

Sri Lanka has a multiplicity of non-correlated Statutes, with responsibility of enforcement by several agencies, whereby notwithstanding all the good intentions, the menace of corruption became worse. What Sri Lanka needs today, given the political commitment, is the enactment of an all-encompassing Statute to fulfil all the obligations stipulated in the Articles of the UNCAC, and a multi-disciplinary Agency for investigation and prosecution, with private expertise and foreign technical assistance drawn where necessary. This needs to be on a planned strategy, with private expertise with the education of the investigators, prosecutors, judiciary, et al, and also with the education of the public of the consequences of corruption, and the offences under such Statute, with preventive measures also put in place. All being equal before the law and ruled by the law, such investigations and prosecutions should be non-selective, regardless of the status and standing of personalities, sans any socio-political considerations. In certain States investigations and prosecutions are closely monitored through interaction of teams or by supervisory oversight and/or with review by civil society representatives.

The writer is  
Sri Lanka’s Co-ordinator for International Association of Anti-Corruption Authorities;
Associate Member, American Bar Association; 
Director, International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management

Order Gifts to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Vegetables, Grocery, Flowers, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Sending Money,Online Books, Delivery Service, Food Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop Sri Lanka

  Comments - 0

Order Gifts to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Vegetables, Grocery, Flowers, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Sending Money,Online Books, Delivery Service, Food Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop Sri Lanka

Add comment

Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Reply To:

Name - Reply Comment

Order Gifts to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Vegetables, Grocery, Flowers, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Sending Money,Online Books, Delivery Service, Food Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop Sri Lanka

Health System in the emergency room

Sandya Kumari from Kotahena has been experiencing chest pains since 2015 and

Canada’s targeted sanctioning of Gota and Mahinda

History was made last week when two former executive presidents of Sri Lanka

SC judgement on Easter attack: Court rules negligence stood in the way of avoiding most heinous crime

“On the ill-fated day of 21st of April 2019, this island home was awoken ru

Lasantha was a Fearless Editor who Spoke Truth to Power

Friends,Family members, colleagues, schoolmates and admirers of Lasantha Wick