Absence of a National Ideology of Reconciliation

15 August 2012 07:54 pm - 4 - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}

A A A

By Dr. Deepika Udagama
There are many views about what we must achieve in post-war Sri Lanka. There appears to be a general acceptance that reconciliation among the various ethnic groups in the country is of topmost priority. Some think that for reconciliation to be realized we must primarily focus on economic development; others think that we must focus on a political solution; yet others think that what is of crucial importance is the investigation of alleged war crimes and establishing the truth; some are of the opinion that all those measures are necessary. There are indicators and bench marks developed to measure reconciliation. Most are about specific deliverables—devolution of power, resettlement of IDPs, demilitarization, equitable land policy, depoliticization of institutions and so on.

But have we, as a society, sufficiently invested our efforts at adopting a philosophy or fundamental principles on reconciliation that should inform our efforts in the post-war period? I do not think so. We have only the same fragmented and hackneyed political rhetoric of our troubled past. There is a palpable absence of a national ideology that guides us in our efforts today. Even if the goal posts for reconciliation are identified, I wish to pose the question whether we can meaningfully achieve any of those goals without the establishment of a dominant ideology of reconciliation? Can there be reconciliation in an ideological vacuum? Can reconciliation be achieved through clinical and technical policies not accompanied by an overarching spirit of reconciliation? I think not.

Recently I was asked by a multi-ethnic group of Sri Lankan expatriates in Australia what reconciliation really means. The dictionary informs us that reconciliation is“to cause to be friendly or harmonious again”. What exactly is the measure though I was asked. My gut response was that it is about creating a genuine sense of equal belonging. Reconciliation is a process that should address the psychological rather than the physical. It is not about the written agreements, handshakes or the visuals. It is this belief that drives me to say that adopting an ideology of reconciliation, with clearly-identified constituent principles, should have been our first priority.
The armed forces decisively defeated the LTTE destroying its military capability. There was then a clear victor and a vanquished. Instead of change, the political status quo at the centre got further entrenched. If there was hope for a progressive vision for reconciliation and reconstruction, such a vision did not emerge following euphoria over the military victory. The imagination of the political establishment seemed to go only so far as embracing triumphalism. No lyrical politics here. No poetry in the heart.

There were no moments of silence or days of mourning to remember the thousands of citizens killed on both sides of the conflict. There were the good ones and the bad ones; a clear victor and a vanquished; patriots and traitors. In such a polarized political backdrop, the creation of a new constitutional order enabling reconciliation was certainly not in the cards; nor was a well-thought- out vision on reconciliation.

Instead what we got was the Eighteenth Amendment to the 1978 Constitution. Even those jubilant over the war victory were troubled both by the Amendment’s contents and the process followed for its adoption. The Amendment, as we all know well, further concentrated power in an already powerful executive presidency. The presidential term limit was removed, and the president got virtually unlimited authority to decide on the composition of the higher judiciary, the Election Commission, the Human Rights Commission, the Police Commission and other institutions the independence of which is crucial to providing checks and balances in government. Further, the powers of some institutions were diluted. The Eighteenth Amendment Bill was rushed through parliament as an urgent Bill, thereby denying consultation and debate. Mysteriously, around that time several opposition parliamentarians joined government ranks swelling its parliamentary majority to the required two-thirds majority. All those events left a bad taste in the mouth of the alert citizen, whether belonging to the majority or a minority. The international community got worried. Things were moving fast, but in a very problematic direction. The historic moment was being squandered on hard politics.

An ideology of reconciliation cannot be built without the basic ingredients of democracy and the rule of law. Economic development is important, but that process alone cannot achieve reconciliation. In the first place, all communities must have the ability to meaningfully enagage in the decision making process in order that development may touch the lives of the people. That is why the likes of President Mandela first invested in a vibrant democratic constitutional order that guaranteed equal protection of rights through the rule of law.

My own set of immediate demands as a citizen are as follows—roll back the Eighteenth Amendment; restore the Seventeenth Amendment and the Constitutional Council with improvements; guarantee judicial independence and independence of all oversight bodies; stop political interference in and politicization of public institutions; take strong measures to prevent discrimination based on ethnicity, gender, language and religion; let law enforcement (meaning the ordinary law--not exceptional laws) take its own course, do not provide protection to erring political favourites; respect and protect free expression, association and assembly-- adopt a policy of ‘let a thousand flowers bloom’; adopt a zero tolerance policy on torture, abductions and involuntary disappearances; permit free and fair elections and respect the people’s will.

That is already asking for a great lot. But without those fundamentals I doubt very much that we can progress in the right direction, both nationally and internationally.

Comments - 4

sunila mendis Thursday, 16 August 2012 04:29 AM

Dr. Deepika udagama has written a very inspiring article.What she is asking the Government to do is like asking a tortoise for feathers. Hence priority no. 1 should be for the intellectuals to create a public opinion so as to push the Govt out of power. Then prepare an agenda for true reconciliation and democratic governance where all ethnic groups would feel a genuine sense of equal belonging.Education has to play a crucial role in this exercise of building self esteem among the vanquished.

P.L.J.B.Palipana Thursday, 16 August 2012 11:43 PM

I too accept Sunila Mendis's comment. This regime must be changed as soon as possible.

buffaloa citizen Friday, 17 August 2012 11:42 AM

Excellent article.

Austin Fernando Friday, 17 August 2012 05:12 AM

Congrats Deepika for the eloquent way you have put across your ideas on reconciliation. While agreeing with the "prescription" you have given in the penultimate paragraph, I may say what the government is doing, (i.e. development for reconciliation) should not cease. But as I have said sometime back in the Daily Mirror devastated minds cannot be healed only through development. This is what has been either little understood by authorities or understood but ignored.

Add comment
Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Absence of a National Ideology of Reconciliation

Comments - 4

Add comment

RECOMMENDED

Focus on Laggala Gem mining big shots bigger than the law

How and why the TNA was formed twenty years ago

India lays emphasis on culture diplomacy with Sri Lanka

Bittersweet memories of a ‘City that never slept’

Revisiting the Attack on Thirukumar Nadesan in India

Spotlight on Attorney General’s Department and Public Service Commission

How a 19-year-old TikToker is helping bring back the Woolly Mammoth!

Most Viewed in News

Mahela to leave SL team after today’s game

Sri Lankan mother kills her two daughters in Italy

Govt. approves cattle slaughter ban

Sri Lanka denies allegations over participation at Dubai EXPO

Those who used it to capture power won’t stay long: Cardinal

Yohani to make her Bollywood debut

TODAY'S HEADLINES

Outrage over post given to controversial monk

SL maintains balance between environment and human needs

Discussions in making vaccine cards mandatory underway: Health Ministry

SJB will not allow anyone to make SL a playing field in geopolitics

MIRROR CRICKET

England take early T20I series lead over Sri Lanka

New Zealand clinch World Test title

LPL 2nd edition from July 30-August 22-SLC

Sanath Jayasuriya signs as coach at Melbourne cricket club Mulgrave

Clinical England thrash Bangladesh in T20 World Cup

SLC stance unchanged on cricketers taking a knee

Dialog in staggering deal to sponsor AR7’s

Ben Gollings to coach SL at Asian Sevens Series