Magistrate: how can court become party to persecution of refugee?

21 September 2011 04:30 am - 3 - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}

A A A

“Handing over a refugee to Sri Lanka where he fears persecution will make us nothing short of abettors,” a magistrate court here said on Tuesday. It turned down the Centre's plea to deport a Tamil refugee, who has been in India for the past 20 years.

In his order, Arul Varma, Metropolitan Magistrate, Court-II, Dwaraka courts, said, “It is unfortunate that in spite of [our] having an impressive record of welcoming refugees, we do not have a national law in place to cater for the specific needs of this class.”

The court said, “An important distinction needs to be made between persons who, on their own volition and in order to earn a livelihood or to explore the world, reach the shores of another country, and a refugee who, under compulsion and duress, has no option but to take shelter in another country. They are a victim of circumstances. They do not throng the shores of another country for pleasure or for any kind of economic gain. They take chances as they do not have choices.”

The judge said the need for enacting comprehensive legislation to deal exclusively with the problems of refugees had arisen from time immemorial, and finally, pursuant to extensive deliberations on a Model National Law: The Refugee and Asylum Seekers (Protection) Bill, 2006 was drafted. But “it is unfortunate that despite its having been drafted after due deliberations and after various rounds of consultations by eminent jurists including the former Chief Justice of India, P. N. Bhagwati, this Bill has not seen the light of the day.”

The court said:

“Presently, the refugees are dealt with under the Foreigners Act, 1946 and the rules framed thereunder. Refugees are treated as foreigners under the extant laws of our country. However, it will be extremely important to understand that a refugee cannot be placed on the same platform on which illegal migrants, tourists and other ‘foreigners' are placed.

“There have been a plethora of instances wherein Indian courts tried to evolve a humane and compassionate approach to redress individual problems; however, in the absence of a long-term, consistent and uniform solution by the way of enactment of national legislation, their treatment would be subject to, and would depend upon the individual outlook, social inclinations and other idiosyncrasies which would make it difficult for the subordinate courts to follow. India needs to live up to its humanitarian goals.”

In the instant case, Chandra Kumar has been staying at a refugee camp at Tiruvallur in Tamil Nadu from 1990. He wanted to eke out a better living in Italy but while leaving India, he was apprehended by immigration authorities as he did not possess valid travel documents. Thereafter, he was charged with cheating, impersonation and forgery and other offences under of the Foreigners Act, 1946. He moved an application for plea bargaining. An order on sentence ought to have been passed forthwith. However, the Additional Public Prosecutor, on instructions from the government, contended that an order of deportation should form part of the order on sentence.

Rejecting the plea for deportation, the court, relying on several Supreme Court judgments, said Indians and non-citizens “are to be treated equally as far as Article 21 of the Constitution (right to life and liberty) is concerned. The very idea of deporting the convict herein to his country of origin, where he has a well-founded fear of persecution, would not be in consonance with the principles of natural justice. How can the court become a party to the persecution of an individual? The court cannot retrograde itself to the position of a mute spectator.”

Since the convict had already been incarcerated for about six months, the court said the sentence already undergone was sufficient punishment and that he should forthwith report back to the tahsildar, Sri Lankan Refugee Camp, Gummidipoondi Taluk. (Source: The Hindu)

Order Gifts to Sri Lanka. See Kapruka's top selling online shopping categories such as Toys, Vegetables, Grocery, Flowers, Birthday Cakes, Fruits, Chocolates, Clothing and Electronics. Also see Kapruka's unique online services such as Money Remittence,News, Courier/Delivery, Food Delivery and over 700 top brands. Also get products from Amazon & Ebay via Kapruka Gloabal Shop into Sri Lanka.

Sell your vehicle & house fast with hitad.lk only cost is Rs.400, Advertise in Hitad.lk for free to sell your mobile phone. Want to sell your Pet, Advertise for Free in hitad.lk Search for Houses in Sri Lanka and find the best place through Hitad.lk find your best tuition place. Find the best partner for you, visit hitad.lk Find anything at any time hitad.lk.

Comments - 3

Leslie Wednesday, 21 September 2011 05:39 AM

The Magistrate has to be commended on his views and for staying the deportation of the Refugee. Trust other Countries would take note of this.

lankaman Wednesday, 21 September 2011 07:36 AM

poor guy will live as a refugee in India. if he comes to SL he will be treated as a respectable citizen. Funny thing is while all developed countries are deporting SL refugees, only lower than SL countries keeping them

sparks Wednesday, 21 September 2011 07:44 AM

A very fine judgment that one will never see happen in Sri Lanka. What more magnanimity can one expect from a great country of the Mahatma and the Buddha.

Add comment
Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Magistrate: how can court become party to persecution of refugee?

Comments - 3

Add comment

RECOMMENDED

Wickremesinghe, Alahapperuma and the 2022 Presidential Election

Versatile Filmmaker Vasantha Obeysekera’s “Dadayama” (The Hunt)

Aragalaya will drag Sri Lanka into chaos and anarchy : Weerawansa

Tamil Parties Must Urge Full Implementation of 13A

Govt. re-recommends COVID-19 regulations: Medics, legal experts warn of vaccine expiry dates and injuries

8-year-old grave sexual abuse victim gets justice after 18 years

Covid makes a comeback!

Most Viewed in News

GR spotted leaving airport in Thailand

Electricity charges to go up by 75% from tomorrow: PUCSL

Retired female state bank AGM arrested over Rs.68 Mn fraud

Customs notify travellers to refrain from bringing prohibited, restricted commodities

Sri Lanka imposes ban on three new entities and 55 individuals

Gotabaya Rajapaksa advised to remain indoors for security reasons at Bangkok hotel

TODAY'S HEADLINES

Prez has not learned anything from the past: Ven.Sobitha Thera

Lanka Confectionery Manufacturers say Certain elements spreading false propaganda to destroy confectionery industry

Fuel stolen from bowser

SJB MP Eran to head COPE

MIRROR CRICKET

England take early T20I series lead over Sri Lanka

New Zealand clinch World Test title

LPL 2nd edition from July 30-August 22-SLC

Sanath Jayasuriya signs as coach at Melbourne cricket club Mulgrave

Isipathana reign supremacy dethroning Royal

Lankan athletes need more foreign exposure – NOCSL

Lankan athletes Sarangi, Sumedha fall short in finals

IPG comes forward as Ground Rights Holder and Broadcast Production for SLC’s T20 Invitational