Mass killing of cattle, again?

15 July 2020 12:01 am - 14     - {{hitsCtrl.values.hits}}


State efforts are underway to import 2500 milch cows from Australia, despite a similar scheme carried out by the previous ‘Yahapalana’ government which saw many lapses. Recently, the Cabinet approved a proposal to import another 2500 milch cows while there were many controversies behind past projects, according to experts’ views.   

In December 2019, many dairy farmers who purchased imported dairy heifers raised their voices on the dire crisis which they had to face with the looming threat of losing their property, in a battle to survive. Those who joined the dairy business recently had trusted the previous government and purchased dairy heifers following an import deal with Australia’s largest cattle exporter, Wellard Ltd.  

“They were supposed to give us pregnant animals but I was given animals that hadn’t conceived too. As soon as we bought the animals, the animals ended up dying,” small scale dairy farmer alleged during the Daily Mirror’s visit to their isolated farms in December 2019.   
The project runs back to 2012, where then Minister Basil Rajapaksa had commenced the import of heifers under an agreement with Australia’s Wellard Ltd. Under the 2012 programme, the government imported 2000 milch cows and through artificial insemination, these cows gave birth to nearly 1500 calves which were initially distributed among dairy farmers in the Dry Zone.   

Due to the success of the first batch, on October 16, 2014, the Australian company and the Sri Lankan government signed an agreement to import another 20,000 milch cows to boost small and medium scale dairy farmers with an ambitious goal of making Sri Lanka self-sufficient in dairy farming by 2016.   
After the‘Yahapalana’ government came into power in 2015, the government started continuing the project by importing another 5000 batch of dairy heifers in May 2015, and several failures had been observed during the importing process.   

The proprietor of Lammermoore Estate in Maskeliya, Amal Suriyage explained to the Daily Mirror that according to the agreement if the ‘Yahapalana’ government needed, they could have stopped importing the remaining 15,000 cows.   
“I bought 200 milch cows from the second stage of the project in May 2015. However, all of them died after they had been imported. All the animals were in poor condition during their arrival in December 2018. Only after they had been imported, we understood that these heifers were infected with Bovine Viral Diarrhoea (BVD), which is a serious disease. I had a mass burial ground at that time, not a farm,” he lamented. 

Shocking financial revelations  

At the Presidential Commission, which was appointed to probe into the corruption occurred within the period between 2015 and 2018, the dairy farmers’ grievances were taken up for debate, where some startling revelations surfaced pertaining to the importation of 20,000 milch cows.   
During the testimony it was revealed that Foresight Engineering (Pvt.) Ltd served as the local agent for Wellard Rural Exports (Pvt.) Ltd, Australia. Several farmers informed the Commission that the officials attached to the Ministry of Rural Economic Development told them that these pregnant cows would produce 20 litres of milk per day on average, and went on to advise some investors to even get rid of the local cows from their farms.   
In the vicinity of these revelations, it was also revealed to the Commission that each cow was valued at nearly Rs. 550,000 and that the ministry gave the cows at a subsidised rate of Rs. 200,000 to the farmers. The total cost of the project was more than Rs.13,500,000,000.   

By March 2018, the ‘Yahapalana’ government imported 5000 milch cows and the project had already faced with several difficulties. At a time when the project needed numerous course corrections, in April 2018, former Secretary of the Rural Economic Development Ministry Renuka Ekanayake recommended a payment of another US$11 million to Wellard Exports, subsequently obtaining former line Minister P. Harrison’s approval.  
Testifying before the Commission, former Chief Accountant attached to the Rural Economic Development Ministry Anton Perera informed the Commission that although the External Resources Department of the Treasury had paid Rs.1.3 billion (US$ 8.3 million) to Wellard Exports on May 8, 2018, there was no budgetary allocation for the project in the 2018 budget. During the proceedings it was also revealed that the Ministry of Rural Economic Development did not acquire the original copy of the agreement which the ministry signed with Wellard in 2014. Ministry’s then Additional Secretary Dharmasiri Ariyapala informed the Commission that he was unable to furnish an original copy of the agreement.   
“The agreement was signed in 2014. The ministry only had a copy of that agreement and I brought a certified copy of that document,” Ariyapala informed the Commission. He also said that Project Coordinator, Sagarika Sumanasekera had informed him that the Ministry of Economic Development did not furnish them with the original copy, despite a request was made. 

The Ministry of Economic Development’s own internal audit department had conducted an internal audit with regard to the matter and according to the report

  • By May 2016, govt. had spent Rs. 88,058,958 on the project and that amount was already a burden to the government due to several reasons.
  • The government had failed to get insurance for imported cows and by May 30, 2016, almost 133 cows died, incurring a loss of Rs. 55,244,535 to the government.
  • According to the agreement signed on July 24, 2014, Wellard Rural Exports Pvt. Ltd agreed to provide as much as Jersey cattle breed required during the importation. By October 2015 the government had imported 2,495 cows and only 1,053 belonged to Jersey cattle breed
  • If these animals were retained at Ridiyagama farm for a longer period, the government must implement an alternative solution such as solar power panels to get electricity to create artificial environment. But the government had failed to establish such processes within this project

Disclosures in 2018 Special Audit Report

The ministry’s own internal audit department had conducted an internal audit with regard to the matter and according to the report, by May 2016 the government had spent Rs. 88,058,958 on the project and that amount was already a burden to the government due to several reasons. According to the report, the government had failed to get insurance cover for the imported cows, and by May 30, 2016, almost 133 cows had been dead and incurred a loss of Rs. 55,244,535 to the government.   
The report also mentioned that according to the agreement signed on July 24, 2014,Wellard Rural Exports (Pvt.) Ltd agreed to provide Jersey cattle breed. By October 2015 the government had imported 2,495 cows and only 1,053 among them were Jersey cows. The Ministry also had to appoint a special committee to check the loan repayment, but it was not appointed till March 2018.  
It was also revealed that if these animals were retained at Ridiyagama farm for a long period, the government must have implemented an alternative solution, such as solar power panels to get electricity to create an artificial environment. But the government had failed to establish such processes within this project.   
Due to above reason, in 2015 the government had spent Rs.5, 729, 028 to generate electricity to keep the animals in an artificial environment and by 2016 the expenses doubled to Rs. 39,993,949. 

Silent and imported deadly killer 

By conducting the project, the former government had also imported a silent killing disease along with these animals. Although the Ministry of Rural Economic Development issued continual warning on the deadly disease, which was carried by the Milch cows, the Ministry had failed to take proper action on the matter.   
“There was no effective treatment or vaccine for BVD. The disease, not only causes death, but also spreads rapidly infecting healthy cattle as well. The disease was never reported in the country prior to the arrival of these cattle from Australia,” former Veterinary Surgeon Rohan Perera told the Daily Mirror. 

New plan to overcome previous issues

Against this backdrop, the incumbent government has taken a decision to import 2500 cattle under the Agriculture Ministry’s ‘Saubhagya Project.’   
Highlighting the new developments to the project, National Livestock Development Board (NLDB) Chairman, Prof. Manjula Magammana said that the Ministry had decided to terminate the existing agreement on importing of cattle. “The Ministry had decided to terminate the existing agreement and there will be a scope change of the whole project,” he said.   
Prof. Magammana said that according to the current plan, the 2500 cattle planned to be imported were not be distributed among dairy and livestock farmers but rather to farms under the NLDB for breeding purposes. He said Sri Lanka never imported any animal previously until 2012, but after implementing decisions to increase agricultural production, the country had started importing animals.   

Increasing agricultural production and improving the quality of milk and meat are key areas to increase food security in the country. “The country is currently trying to take some innovative steps considering nuclear and nuclear-derived techniques to control and prevent diseases among livestock and boost cattle and milk production,” he said.   
While addressing the issues pertaining to the previous cattle imports by the ‘Yahapalana’ government, he said there was a serious issue in the quarantine process conducted for these animals. “Whoever made the decision to issue the imported animals directly to farmers was totally against the principles. There should be a proper quarantine process for these animals before handing them over to farmers. Having a quarantine process in place only we can recognise the behavior and the diseases of these animals,” he said.   
He said that the country could have controlled BVD, if the animal health authorities had conducted a proper quarantine for these animals. “Normally, when we maintain a dairy farm, if there is a breakdown in the first three years, no profit could be achieved during that period. From the fourth year onwards, dairy farmers could yield profits from their business,” he said.   Prof. Magammana said according to the present project, the Ministry had decided to train farmers who wish to start a dairy farm upon the promise that the Ministry would implement a National Dairy Development Centre for learning purposes.   
“Most farmers who purchased cattle from the previous project, were new to the business and they did not receive training. 60% of their income had been used to feed these animals and it was not a healthy situation for a dairy farming industry. We have to follow certain protocols when managing a dairy farm,” Prof. Magammana said.  

  Comments - 14

  • Sandun Wednesday, 15 July 2020 03:45 PM

    Nobody cares about cattles. They make a scene only for deaths of elephants and leopards. Ironic!!

    Martin Milton Wednesday, 15 July 2020 05:23 PM

    This criminal massacre of innocent Milk Cows MUST stop forthwith. If this present GOSL makes the same mistakes that the Yahapalanaya GOSL did they will reap the ire of the people AND alal deity protecting Sri Lanka. Let those foolish Ministers realise this.

    Martin Wednesday, 15 July 2020 06:36 PM

    Instead of importing Cows why not release each and every Cow and calf from all the slaughter houses through Sri Lanka. These will deliver good fresh milk. BUT please do NOT starve the poor calves. Please remember it is THEIR MOTHER's Milk that these people will be stealing. Milk is an essential food item for only a very small percentage of the population as the Calcium in it is never absorbed by the body. Adults do NOT need Milk to survive.

    Martin Wednesday, 15 July 2020 06:37 PM

    It is a grave fallacy! Imported Milk Powder from NZ/ Australia can supplement Sri Lanka's needs. PLEASE save the innocent COWS and CALVES from slaughter.. ALL cattle will be better saved. Eating meat also causes CANCER! Remember that!.

    Sokrates Thursday, 16 July 2020 09:26 AM

    The problem is not the cows, but the farmers who lack the necessary knowledge to properly treat these highly bred and highly productive cows.

    Ranjit Wijesinha Thursday, 16 July 2020 03:20 PM

    Nimitta, Thursday 16 July 2020 Don,t import cattle. Import milk powder from Australia/NZ. I live in Australia and drink soy milk. Don't eat meat or eat meat once a fortnight

    Kim Thursday, 16 July 2020 07:20 PM

    Our local farmers have no knowledge or expertise how to look after milch cows. Besides these cows are well looked after and roam freely in the outback of Australia. We don't even have the necessary feed or enough space for there cows to roam freely in search of food and are often seen feeding on garbage. We can't even care for our wild life and the lives of these cows too will be in danger both from man and wild animals. It could be considered a crime to import these cows to Sri Lanka and see them suffer and die like last time.

    Sambo Thursday, 16 July 2020 10:13 PM

    All they want is commission and nothing else. Not for the love of the poor farmer.

    Bull Friday, 17 July 2020 12:34 AM

    This is what happens when we try to fly with bullock carts.

    Moo Moo Friday, 17 July 2020 12:56 AM

    Looks like somebody was milking the system, not the cows.

    Hari M Saturday, 18 July 2020 08:13 PM

    You have a neighbour India, from which Brazil imports cows such as Gir, Kangkrej breeds which are good milkers. Yet we need to import 1000's of miles from Australia breeds that does not suit our climate and expertise.

    MLK Monday, 20 July 2020 02:52 PM

    Why when we have so many, we can see them out nowadays

    dickie bird Tuesday, 21 July 2020 05:58 PM

    Import the Cows from India. They have in abundance

    RP Thursday, 23 July 2020 08:15 AM

    Why? We failed miserably during our earlier attempt and trying again. Did we get adequate training this time or is it De Ja Vu'? Poor Australian cows. In my opinion, they'd better off in the Australian slaughterhouse than our pasture lands!

Add comment

Comments will be edited (grammar, spelling and slang) and authorized at the discretion of Daily Mirror online. The website also has the right not to publish selected comments.

Reply To:

Name - Reply Comment

My time is up – Mahinda Deshapriya

With just hours to go before the 2020 Parliamentary Election, Election Commis

Anuruddha Sampayo remanded till tomorrow

Former Negombo Prison Superintendent Anuruddha Sampayo, who was taken into th

A response to DM exposé on Tea Promotion Officer

With reference to the Daily Mirror Expose article and Page 1 news item, both

Tea promoting officer in hot water!

Astonishing revelations underscore how Sri Lanka Tea Board (SLTB), the promot